Debt Doesn't Need to be a Four-Letter Word:
A Guide to Debt Financing
By Mark W. Sheffert
March 1999
There’s an old joke that says, "If you ever need a heart transplant, be sure you get a
lender’s heart … because you know it’s never been used!" Well…as former bankers
we know this is just a joke … uh, er, right?!
While lenders can sometimes be ornery (especially if their loan isn’t being paid),
borrowers need to share some of the blame for their lender’s congeniality (or lack of it).
Small business owners and entrepreneurs are oftentimes good salespeople, and, being
natural optimists and risk-takers, they will put themselves in debt, then … see if they can
sell their way out of it!
Too often, business owners are so anxious to get a loan they don’t take the
time to make sure it’s the right type of loan with the right terms and conditions. Being
over-leveraged or having the wrong debt structure is a major reason why so many
businesses fail. While we cannot guarantee business success, we can guide you through
the most common forms of debt financings, ranging from short-term to long-term debt
structures:
- Trade debt financing (the most fundamental of all financings) is utilizing the full
terms granted by your trade creditors (suppliers), or even stretching out payments
beyond normal 30-day terms. Although trade debt financing is often an option,
requires no collateral, and offers flexibility, there are hidden costs. In addition to
friction created between you and your suppliers, some creditors will charge late
fees (typically 1 _ percent per month) and you may forfeit financial benefits from
discounts on early payment. For example, not taking advantage of discount terms
of 2/10, net/30 can result in losing an opportunity cost of over 18 percent. Almost
all businesses can take advantage of trade debt financing to some extent in order
to optimize their cash flow; at the very least, you should utilize trade terms to
their fullest.
- Factoring is selling accounts receivable to a lender at a discounted rate and
without recourse to your company. While you receive cash immediately, discount
rates are high (typically ranging from 2 to 15 percent). On an annualized basis,
this could mean a cost higher than 50 percent. Factoring is helpful only to
businesses with extreme short-term cash needs that cannot, for whatever reason,
obtain traditional bank financing.
- Bank loans to businesses are frequently written as 90-day notes. Generally
appearing on a company’s financial statement as "notes payable", the 90-day note
is secondary in importance to trade credit as a source of short-term financing. It
usually provides financing for a singular purpose and is priced aggressively ---
floating at or above a short-term index such as the prime rate. Although an
excellent source of financing, a 90-day note is typically available only to the most"credit-worthy" companies with a strong cash flow, balance sheet, and history of
profitable operations. Ironically, when your company is in the best position from
a credit risk standpoint is when typically you need it the least!
- A line of credit is an agreement between a lender and your company for loans
up to a specified committed amount (commonly referred to as asset-based,
receivable, or inventory financing). It typically allows for multiple advances (not
exceeding the maximum amount the lender has agreed to commit) and repayment
of the line of credit over the committed term. Your company will most likely have
to provide collateral, usually consisting of short-term current assets such as
inventory and receivables. Credit advances are based on a borrowing formula of
a percentage of inventory and receivable values (typically 75 percent of current
receivable balances and 50 percent of viable inventory balances). The lender will
charge an interest rate that fluctuates at or above the prime rate, and a
commitment fee of one to three percent of the committed line of credit amount. A line of credit is a good source of financing for manufacturing and distribution
companies with short-term working capital needs.
- A term loan is a contract under which your company agrees to make a series of
interest and principal payments on specific dates to a lender. You will need to
show the lender that your cash flow will cover monthly payments (called debt
service) and you will need to commit collateral such as equipment (long-term
equipment financing) or real estate (mortgage financing). A fixed rate will most
likely be put in place for the entire duration of the loan and appraisals on the
equipment or real estate may have to be completed at your expense. Term loans
are a good fit for companies with large amounts of fixed assets and equipment
such as manufacturing, farming, and construction-related businesses.
- Lease financing is a monthly rental / lease fee for equipment, rather than an out
right purchase of equipment. Lease financing is similar to term loan financing
and is a popular form of financing for capital-intensive businesses with high
investments in fixed assets or equipment that becomes obsolete quickly (like
computers). The two most common types of leases are:
- Operating leases, sometimes called service or true leases, provide both
financing and maintenance. They are typically short term and, when
completed, have not fully amortized the asset. At the end of the term of the
lease, you will return the asset to the leasing company. This type of lease is
a good fit for companies that do not want to capitalize equipment and
incur liabilities on their balance sheet.
- Financial leases, sometimes called capital leases, are more long term in
duration. They also do not provide for maintenance service, are not
cancelable, and are fully amortized when completed. Financial leases are
considered to be a type of long-term debt financing, and therefore the asset
is capitalized and the offsetting liability is recorded on your balance sheet.
- Although we don’t have room in this article to discuss them, other specialized
types of debt financings include hybrid forms of debt financing with equity
conversion options, such as mezzanine financing and convertible debentures.
Whichever option you decide, applying for commercial credit can be complex and
requires a significant amount of preparation on your behalf. To increase your likelihood
of success, you should prepare a credit initiation memorandum with complete financial
information, an abbreviated business plan, and an explanation of the purpose and
repayment plan for the debt. We can’t stress enough the importance of a good credit
initiation memorandum and business plan!
Loan documents aren’t exactly known for being user-friendly, and can contain
such provisions as negative and positive covenants, 10 percent offset-rules, unused line
fees, etc. If you are confused about all the options and loan document provisions, or
don’t have the time or skills to prepare the credit initiation memorandum and business
plan, consult an expert in financing for assistance. This expert should also be able to
help you identify which type of financing is right for you and where you can obtain the
optimal amount of credit with the best terms.
Choose a financial institution with a reputation for supporting small, growing
businesses. Some lenders focus principally on consumers, so choose one that is in touch
with your needs --- ask other entrepreneurs who are their sources for credit, and their
experiences in obtaining financing.
Lenders want to do business with companies that can demonstrate their ability
to repay the debt. You will need to show the lender that your cash flow projections
will cover monthly payments and that you have build sufficient collateral (accounts
receivable, inventory, and equipment) to cover the value of the loan in case of default.
Financing is a continual process for growing companies. By making sure that you
find the right types and terms of debt financing for your company … debt will not
become a four-letter word for you.
Back to Top |